Good Feedback
I had a lovely little email from my Fantastic Literature professor this morning, regarding the segment of my story that I had sent him earlier. I was a little worried that he'd respond with something like, "Alaina, I'm a bit concerned that you learned nothing in this class. Your story won't work unless you completely rewrite it. Sorry". Happily, this wasn't the case. Here's what he wrote, translated back into English of course:
Good evening, Alaina,
I'll rapidly give you my opinion about your story:
- It's a very good idea to start the story with a direct entry by the intermediary of a session with a psychiatrist. The idea that this begins your tale is equally an element that gives some credibility and also some dramatic intensity.
- You then present an element that merits a response: the ecstasy pills. Then a strange event intervenes that perterbs the readers: this very personal dream of which Marc does not want to speak. Then the reader questions himself. Finally, the story tells us, later, that the ecstacy was in reality no more than aspirin. It is very good since the formulated hypothesis by the reader since the beginning doesn't work any longer. And all of a sudden, other questions present themselves ... many questions ... about the personality of Max, about his friend Marc, about Max's father, etc.
- The dream, that you will explain or not, complexifies and complicates the story. And this as well is a welcome element that the reader doesn't understand, for most of the story, what has happened, or what could have happened, and ... that what is to come. From this point of view, the structure of your story succeeds perfectly.
You don't need to add any additional events or elements. Your story is sufficiently rich.
In conclusion, go ahead, you have in your hands the means to write an excellent fantastical story.
See you tomorrow, (prof).
I could turn it in today, but I'd rather wait until next week so I have some time to revise some of the poor grammar.









2 Comments:
Hee hee....funny cheap umbrella shot. You get what you pay for.
p.s. Great comments from your prof....you were always a great storyteller/make-upper/b.s.er
Way to go!
Post a Comment
<< Home